🎄 Christmas Offer: Get 25% off with code CHRISTMAS2026 — Shop Now →

Why a Physical Holiday Gift Beats Cash for Your Team (and How to Make It Personal)

A wrapped holiday gift versus cash: why a physical gift for your team wins

Research shows that a thoughtful, useful gift can have a bigger effect than cash of the same value, especially when it feels personal.

Holiday gifts for employees are often a quick decision: a gift card, a fruit basket or a candle holder nobody really asked for. That is understandable: it is easy and rarely goes completely wrong.

But the difference between a holiday gift that gets appreciated and one that gets forgotten is rarely about the amount. It is about whether the gift is generic or thoughtful: whether it shows that someone actually thought about the person receiving it.

The research: thermos vs. cash

In a classic field study in the American Economic Review (Kube, Maréchal & Puppe, 2012), people were hired for a short job entering library catalogue data. Some received an extra 7 euros in cash, others a thermos worth the same amount.

The cash had no measurable effect on performance. The thermos raised productivity by about 25%. When participants could choose, most of them took the money. Even so, they performed as if they had received a gift.

The study's most telling result: the biggest effect (about 29%) came from the same 7 euros handed over folded into an origami shirt, with a smiley drawn on the coin. Same amount, but with visible care. So it is not the amount that decides, but whether the gift shows that someone put thought into it.

What this means for you: a useful, physical holiday gift (for example a hoodie, sweatshirt or tote bag people actually want) is likely a better choice than a cash bonus of the same value. (The study was done with temporary workers, so treat the numbers as a direction rather than a promise.)

The personal touch makes the difference

Two studies point the same way. In two field experiments at work, Bradler & Neckermann (2019) found that money and appreciation each work on their own, but only work well together when combined with a personal touch.

Pizzetti et al. (2024) showed in four experiments that recipients appreciate a customized gift more, because they feel a kind of pride in what the giver created. In one of the experiments, participants gave clothes to a friend. The researchers' advice: tell the recipient how and why the gift was customized. (The study looked at friends, not colleagues, but the principle is the same.)

So consider adding a message alongside your company logo. The logo says "you work here". An extra message says "this is for you".

With us you can add several prints to the same product, for example:

  • Logo on the chest or sleeve + a team message on the back ("Team X", "Best team ever!")
  • Logo + the year
  • Logo + a short phrase that reflects your culture, not just your brand

It is still the same product for the whole team and just as easy to order, but the print becomes unique to this Christmas and to your team. Include a few lines about why you chose the message and the gift gets its full effect (you can easily add a note to the invitation email your team receives).

Material gifts create more small moments of happiness

In one of their studies, Weidman & Dunn (2016) followed how happy participants felt in the moment with a holiday gift they had received, during the weeks after Christmas. Material gifts gave small moments of happiness more often over time, while experiences gave more intense feelings but on fewer occasions.

A t-shirt that gets worn for years is exactly that kind of gift: it shows up in everyday life again and again, not just on the day the package is opened.

Three things that make corporate holiday gifts fail

  1. Wrong size → the garment ends up at the back of the wardrobe.
  2. Disposable feel and cheap quality → it ends up in the bin as early as January.
  3. Arrives after Christmas → the whole point of a holiday gift is lost.

Checklist for this year's holiday gift

  • Choose a garment people want to wear, not the cheapest one
  • Add a message on top of the logo and explain why you chose it
  • Order in time so packages reach every home before Christmas
  • Order only what you need: choose a supplier that doesn't make you order more than you need

See how it works on our page about Christmas gifts for employees. Right now you get 25% off with the code CHRISTMAS2026 (until 24 December). Order by 6 December for delivery before Christmas.

Frequently asked questions

Is a holiday gift better than a cash bonus for employees?

Often, if the gift is thoughtful. In a field experiment, a thermos worth 7 euros raised productivity by about 25%, while the same amount in cash had no measurable effect (Kube et al., 2012).

Don't employees prefer money?

Many say so. But in the same study, the workers who chose money still performed as well as those who received a gift. It is the thought that carries the most weight.

What is a good holiday gift for a remote team?

Something useful, shipped to each person's home in the right size and in good quality that gets used again and again. A hoodie, t-shirt or coffee mug with your logo and a team message works well.

How do you make a corporate holiday gift personal?

Add a message on top of the logo and tell your team why you chose it. Research shows that a personal touch and visible customization increase appreciation (Bradler & Neckermann, 2019; Pizzetti et al., 2024).

Sources